Alright so I've now officially pulled the soapbox out from under the counter and dusted it off.

One of my biggest beefs with American Idol judging is that they weigh so much of their commentary on a song choice and whether or no they were "bored". Silly me, I thought they were supposed to be judging on talent, on singing ability, on a contestants ability to sing ANY given song. Instead when a contestant tries to pull of a slower (gasp!) more melodic song they are essentially crucified on stage! Never mind that some of the most memorable songs EVER written were slower than molasses in January and yet still capable of stirring the soul.

Ok ok so I'm a bit jaded because of the treatment Ramiele received last night but I still think that my argument is a valid one. I've seen far to many great singers get a bad Simon review (and that IS the kiss of death) simply because he was bored and compelled to make some repetitive reference to a lounge or cabaret or something. Sidenote: How did Simon become such an expert on Cabaret talent? Anyway, I do hope that America is capable of seeing past the steering campaign that is in place with the judging crew and that they will vote based on overall talent and ability.

Here's to hoping! -Matt

---